How about it, Watson?

In this episode, Luke, Westy, and Matt tell the behind-the-scenes story of Rian Johnson’s 2019 whodunit Knives Out. What happens when a director fresh off the most divisive Star Wars film in history decides to write an original murder mystery on spec, with no studio, no cast, and nothing but a lifelong obsession with Agatha Christie? You get a film where James Bond plays a Southern gentleman detective and Captain America wears cable-knit jumpers with the menace of a man who’d happily tell you to eat s*** at a family gathering.

We dig into how Johnson crafted a multi-layered screenplay that borrows from the best of the genre. The parlour-room tension of Sleuth, the structural trickery of The Last of Sheila, the ensemble precision of Murder on the Orient Express, and then flipped the whole thing by revealing the killer in the first act and daring the audience to keep watching anyway. We explore the casting process that brought together one of the decade’s most stacked ensembles, how Ana de Armas went from relative unknown to the emotional centre of a $300 million hit, and why Christopher Plummer’s Harlan Thrombey practically lives in a Clue board.

The production story is just as rich as the film itself. We cover the discovery of the Ames Mansion in Massachusetts and how its labyrinthine layout became a character in its own right, the incredible set design and decoration that turned every room into a visual clue, and Johnson’s approach to building a screenplay so structurally tight that even the donut hole speech somehow makes perfect sense. From Craig’s gloriously committed Kentucky-fried, Foghorn Leghorn drawl to the regurgitative reaction to mistruthing that became the film’s most unlikely plot device, we break down the craft, the choices, and the sheer nerve of a film that proved original storytelling still fills cinemas. Whether you’re a lifelong Agatha Christie devotee, a whodunit sceptic, or someone who just wants to hear three people doing Benoit Blanc impressions, this one’s for you.

Listen to the full episode above, or find All The Right Movies wherever you get your podcasts. Please subscribe on YouTube, Apple Podcasts, Spotify, and Google Podcasts.